A batch of homemade ice cream. Flavor can be a custom flavor chosen by the winner or pick form the list:
Vanilla
Chocolate
Mint chocolate cookie
Maple creme cookie
Cannoli
Creme brulee
Tiramisu
Pina colada
Mango
Pineapple
Nutella
Horchata
Peanut Butter

If you can dream it, Peter can ice-cream it